Economy

Courts must intervene in intra-party affairs to save democray – Retired Justice

…Says court must not replace the ballot box

Advertisement

…Nigeria has highest election litigations in the world, caused by impunity

Nigeria’s democracy is said to face danger in the courts where a judge, not the ballot box, now decides who wins an election. Already, Nigeria has the highest election cases in the world.

This alarm was sounded in a lecture delivered by Oludotun Adefope-Okojie, a retired justice of the Court of Appeal and a fellow of arbitration in the United Kingdom at a conference organized by the Gavel International in Lagos. The dialogue looked at the way internal happenings in the parties have been left entirely to the manipulating party lords and influencers.

The topic dwelt on: ‘Electoral Process in Nigeria: Managing the boundaries of judicial intervention’.

It looked at how the credibility of an electoral system depends not only on the conduct of elections but also on the existence of effective mechanisms for resolving disputes arising before, during, and after elections.

The retired justice declared that faulted the new rule that seemed to oust the power of courts to entertain cases from party primaries or party actions. She insisted that the courts still had powers to entertain such cases. She said: “Courts must intervene in intra-party affairs to save democray”.

She went on: “It is also incumbent on the Courts to change their posture in their refusal to intervene in intra-party affairs but to come down heavily in deserving cases, in order to stop the manipulations going on in the parties, with their unlawful and unjust substitution of deserving candidates by the imposition of undeserving and unelected ones.”

The retired justice made it clear that this has been done by the Supreme Court in the recent unreported case between PDP v Alhaji Sule Lamido in Appeal No. SC/CV/164/2026 delivered on the 30th day of April 2026[1] on the issue of justiciability of internal or domestic affairs of a party. “The Court, in their majority judgment of 3-2, delivered by His Lordship Stephen Jonah Adah JSC, (Tsammani and Abubakar Sadiq Umar JJSC dissenting), while reiterating their position that internal affairs of a party are not justiciable, held that where a political party violates its own constitution and “rubbishes” the Electoral Act and the Constitution, the Court must intervene (Emphasis Mine).”

The retired justice said she agreed with the majority decision in the case. “The Courts must no longer refuse to intervene where political parties violate their own constitution and ‘rubbish’ the Electoral Act, as stated in the case above, they must intervene to sanitise the system. The duty of the Courts is to ensure that justice is done and not to shut its eyes against its bastardisation by the political parties.

“Judicial intervention in electoral disputes is therefore indispensable to the preservation of constitutional government, the enforcement of electoral laws, and the protection of citizens’ political rights.”

Adefope-Okojie stated that through their functions of determining whether candidates satisfy constitutional requirements, elections comply with applicable laws, and persons declared winners were validly elected, the judiciary serves as an institutional safeguard against electoral illegality and arbitrariness.

She showed the central question in the matter: How can Nigerian courts protect electoral integrity and enforce compliance with electoral laws without exceeding their constitutionally defined role or undermining the democratic choices of voters?

Through her paper, she examined the boundaries of judicial intervention in Nigeria’s electoral process and the relationship between that intervention and the constitutional right of Nigerians to choose their representatives through the ballot. Drawing on the 1999 Constitution, the Electoral Act 2026, the decisions of the Supreme Court and the Court of Appeal from 1983 to 2026, and the experience of other African jurisdictions, the United Kingdom and the United States, it argues that judicial intervention is legitimate to the extent that it protects the voters’ choice, and loses legitimacy when it replaces that choice. It identifies two recurring failures, substitution and abdication, and proposes principles and a programme of reform for managing the boundary ahead of the 2027 general election.

She went on: “The ideal situation should be that the vote of the people should be decided at the polling unit, rather than the court of law. The contrary is however the prevalent situation in this country.

“The Political parties have done immeasurable harm to the polity. They seem incapable of abiding by their own Party’s Constitution in their selection of the rightful candidates to be fielded in the election, which, contrarily, in a number of instances has boomeranged against them, with the rightfully elected but rejected candidate working for the opposing side in the actual election, out of spite. The parties have also taken advantage of the Courts’ position of not intervening in the domestic affairs of the party, to commit all manner of atrocities.”

She said it is the flawed congresses and wrongful substitution of successful candidates by imposition of handpicked ones, and an electoral system challenged by honesty, that led to most of the litigations in the past elections.

“At the actual election were accusations of ballot snatching, vote rigging, vote buying, manipulations and outright falsification of results. The resultant effect is the recourse to the Courts for determination of the rightful candidate, a duty which should have been resolved at the polling booth and the rightful declaration by INEC.

“The unfortunate result is that a number of the people in the Legislature, not only at Federal but at State and Local Government levels are not the desire of the electorate. They, in consequence, owe the electorate no duty to represent them. This is an aberration!”

Nigeria: Highest electoral litigants in the world

The retired justice poured figures to show that Nigeria litigates its elections on a scale without parallel among comparable democracies. “The 1,209 petitions that followed the 2023 general elections were filed against 1,280 contested offices: roughly 94 petitions for every 100 seats. Kenya’s comparable figure fell from about 21 petitions per 100 elective seats in 2017 to under 7 in 2022. Ghana’s 2020 parliamentary elections produced about six.

“The United Kingdom has averaged about four petitions a year across all its elections since 1977, most of them local.

South Africa resolved 579 objections at the level of its Electoral Commission in 2024 and saw a single court challenge to the national result, later withdrawn. These figures do not measure the quality of justice. They measure trust, and on that measure the Nigerian electoral process is in severe deficit.
“Secondly, volume has not produced vindication. Only 103 of the 1,209 petitions of 2023 succeeded; the rest were withdrawn, struck out, dismissed or refused. A system in which more than nine in ten petitions fail is not one in which the courts are correcting widespread error.

“Nigeria’s ratio is inflated in part because several petitions are often filed against the same seat. Even allowing for that, it is almost double the next highest and about sixteen times Ghana’s.

“Outside Africa the contrast is sharper. In the United Kingdom, 302 election petitions were lodged across parliamentary, European and local elections between 1900 and 2016, fewer than three a year, and most recent petitions concern local rather than parliamentary results. The last parliamentary election voided by an election court was Oldham East and Saddleworth in 2010.”

She said South Africa routes disputes first to its Electoral Commission. “After the 2024 national elections, the Commission received 579 objections and ordered recounts in 24 instances, while the only court challenge to the national result was withdrawn. The United States records a large volume of election litigation, 756 cases in the 2023–2024 cycle by one count, but most of it concerns the rules of voting before polling day rather than challenges to declared results.”

The volume of petitions is believed to respond to trust: “Kenya’s petitions on elective seats fell from 388 after the annulled 2017 presidential election to 123 in 2022. Second, jurisdictions that filter disputes before they reach the courts, through a credible electoral commission empowered to resolve objections or through strict rules on time and costs, see far fewer cases. Nigeria has no equivalent filter: almost every grievance, save for a cosmetic grievance resolution procedure at the party level, goes straight to the tribunal.

“The simplistic answer to the avoidance or reduction of Judicial intervention in electoral matters is for the parties to comply with the tenets of justice and to observe their various party constitutions in their selection of candidates. It is also for the electoral body to abide by its mandate in its impartial conduct of the elections.”

Court must not overtake the ballot box

Adefope-Okojie argued that Nigeria’s democracy rests on two promises that can pull against each other. “The first is that the people choose their rulers. The second is that every election is governed by law and every grievance can be taken to a court.

“When the courts enforce the law faithfully, the two promises reinforce each other. When courts are drawn into deciding who governs on grounds remote from the vote, the second promise begins to consume the first.”

She observed that since 1999, and especially since 2007, Nigerian courts have become a second electoral arena. Candidates now plan for the tribunal as carefully as for the campaign.

“The phrase ‘go to court’ has become an accepted response to defeat, and a rising number of office-holders, as stated above, owe their seats to judgments rather than to ballots. The Judiciary did not seek this role; the Constitution, the Electoral Act and the weaknesses of electoral administration thrust it upon the courts.”

The jurist talked about trust deficit in the ability of the Courts to render unbiased decisions on electoral litigation. The Chief Justice of Nigeria only just recently cautioned Judges against such practices in view of the 2027 general election. She has also warned that judges on election tribunals will be closely watched.

The crux of her argument at the seminar was that the right of Nigerians to choose their representatives is a composite right. “No single section of the 1999 Constitution states it in one sentence, but it emerges clearly from the structure of the Constitution and from treaties binding on Nigeria.”

Conclusion

She stated: “The answer to Nigeria’s electoral litigation crisis does not lie in the courtroom alone. The comparative evidence suggests that petitions reduce when elections improve, and when disputes are filtered before they reach the courts: by an electoral commission empowered to resolve objections, by parties that conduct credible primaries, and by strict but fair rules on time and costs. Those are matters for INEC, the National Assembly and the political parties.

Nigeria’s experience since 1999 leaves no doubt that the courts are indispensable to its electoral democracy.

“Where ballots have been stolen, it has often been the tribunals and the appellate courts, not the electoral commission or the political class, that restored the people’s verdict.”

She raised a critical question. “The question is therefore not whether the judiciary should intervene in the electoral process, but where intervention must stop if the ballot, rather than the bench, is to remain the source of political authority.”

Her position is that, going forward; popular sovereignty is the interpretive anchor; the Court, in granting a remedy, must treat the effect on voters as a mandatory consideration at the remedy stage; the test of a good election judgment is not only whether it applies the law correctly, but whether, at the end of it, the person who holds office is the person the lawful votes chose, or, if that cannot be known, whether the choice has been returned to the voters.

More; the Courts should prefer a remedy that returns the question to voters, rather than settle it in their stead. Courts should prefer a fresh election or re-run over a declaration in favour of a candidate the voters did not choose; declare a winner only where the lawful votes clearly show who won.

No longer should an election be upheld in favour of a person the electorate did not vote for. The matter must be returned to the electorate for their own choice. Their choice must not be hijacked by the substitution of non-deserving candidates.

It is not the duty of the Courts to award seats. Prefer substance over form, within the rules. Apply procedural rules firmly but proportionately. A defect that causes no injustice should not defeat a petition that deserves an answer; a defect should not be overlooked to reach a preferred result. Legitimacy is the only power courts have.

Her final word

“The Constitution places sovereignty in the people and makes the Courts the guardians of that sovereignty, not its holders. Judicial intervention in elections is justified by the right of Nigerians to choose their representatives, and it must be measured by that right.

“A judgment that corrects a stolen mandate honours it. A judgment that confers a mandate the voters never gave, however lawful in form, diminishes it. The final aim of electoral adjudication should be its own decline: a democracy in which elections are won and lost at the ballot box, not in the courtroom.”

admin

About Author

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may also like

Economy

How Nigerians can buy Anthropic shares as world’s biggest IPO hits Nasdaq

  • November 19, 2026
Nigerians who want to invest in Anthropic will have to buy its shares on the stock market rather than through
Economy

NNPC plans to leverage assets to raise capital under new CBN deal

  • November 19, 2026
The Nigerian National Petroleum Company (NNPC) Limited plans to leverage its balance sheet and assets to raise capital for energy