National News

Fiscal Responsibility: CeFTPI calls for mandatory assessment of government-owned enterprises, sanctions

The Centre for Fiscal Transparency and Public Integrity (CeFTPI) has called for mandatory fiscal accountability assessments of all federal ministries, departments and agencies (MDAs), including government-owned enterprises, after publishing the 2026 Fiscal Responsibility Index.

In a statement on Sunday, Executive Director Umar Yakubu said 17 of the 21 institutions assessed fell below the 50 per cent benchmark, raising concerns about compliance with fiscal regulations and transparency in public resource management.

CeFTPI called for stronger sanctions against institutions that repeatedly violate financial regulations. It also recommended raising the index’s compliance threshold to between 70 and 75 per cent and improving the funding and operational independence of the Fiscal Responsibility Commission (FRC).

Read the full statement below:

PRESS STATEMENT

CeFTPI commends Fiscal Responsibility Commission’s 2026 Index, calls for mandatory assessment of government-owned enterprises, raising compliance thresholds and clear sanctions

The Centre for Fiscal Transparency and Public Integrity (CeFTPI) commends the Fiscal Responsibility Commission (FRC) on the publication of the 2026 Fiscal Responsibility Index, which assessed federal Ministries, Departments and Agencies (MDAs) across the 2023–2025 financial years.

Dangote Refinery AD

As an institution dedicated to promoting open governance and public sector accountability, including through our annual Transparency and Integrity Index (TII) and Nigerian Local Government Integrity Index (NLGII), we welcome the FRC’s evidence-based benchmarking across policy-based budgeting, procurement, transparency and external auditing.

That 17 out of the 21 participating institutions fell below the 50 per cent benchmark underscores the urgency of sustained fiscal oversight.

However, to ensure this exercise translates into systemic reform rather than an annual ritual of dismal scorecards, CeFTPI raises eight critical observations and policy recommendations:

1. Limited scope and the need to focus on government-owned enterprises (GOEs)

While 30 federal ministries initially expressed interest, only 21 ultimately participated in the assessment. Statutory compliance with the Fiscal Responsibility Act (FRA) 2007 is not optional; participation in accountability assessments should be mandatory across all federal MDAs, not voluntary.

More importantly, future editions must prioritise revenue-generating agencies, parastatals and government-owned enterprises (GOEs).

Historically, the most severe cases of fiscal irresponsibility, ranging from unremitted operating surpluses and opaque procurement to off-budget spending, occur within GOEs and specialised agencies rather than core ministries. Leaving these high-spending, revenue-generating entities out of the assessment creates a major blind spot in Nigeria’s fiscal accountability framework.

2. Post-assessment follow-through and remediation

Identifying that only four ministries—Finance; Water Resources; Communications, Innovation and Digital Economy; and Housing and Urban Development—met the 50 per cent threshold is only the first step.

What happens to the 17 institutions that failed? Without structured post-assessment remediation plans, targeted capacity-building and strict timelines for corrective action, low scores risk becoming normalised.

The FRC, alongside the Office of the Secretary to the Government of the Federation (OSGF) and the Budget Office of the Federation, must institute mandatory turnaround frameworks for underperforming institutions.

3. Enforcement, sanctions and amendment of the Fiscal Responsibility Act

Public naming and benchmarking lose their deterrent effect when serial non-compliance carries no tangible consequences.

Under the current Fiscal Responsibility Act 2007, the FRC’s enforcement powers are largely limited to investigating infractions and forwarding reports to the Attorney-General of the Federation for possible prosecution. This mechanism has rarely yielded penalties. CeFTPI reiterates its call on the National Assembly and the Executive to urgently amend the FRA 2007 to empower the Commission with direct administrative sanctions.

Accounting officers and chief executives whose institutions consistently flout statutory financial regulations, fail to publish audited accounts, or breach procurement laws must face clear administrative and legal penalties, including withholding of overhead releases or performance-based sanctions.

4. Proactive public disclosure versus closed-door compliance

While score-reconciliation meetings and document reviews build institutional buy-in, genuine fiscal responsibility requires proactive public disclosure rather than behind-the-scenes submissions to a regulator.

In CeFTPI’s own 2026 Transparency and Integrity Index (TII), which evaluates over 500 federal institutions, a recurring failure across MDAs is the refusal to proactively publish approved budgets, procurement plans and audited financial statements on their official websites, as required by the Freedom of Information (FOI) Act and Financial Regulations. If public records are only produced during an FRC verification session, citizens and civil society still cannot track public resources in real time.

5. Addressing failures in budget transparency and policy linkages

Deeper breakdowns of the 2026 FRC findings show widespread failure across assessed MDAs in budget-policy linkages, comprehensiveness and transparency, including within major capital-spending ministries.

This exposes a structural flaw in Nigeria’s budget preparation cycle, where line items are routinely inserted without clear alignment to Medium-Term Sector Strategies (MTSS) or measurable performance indicators. When high-expenditure ministries fail on budget realism and policy linkage, the direct result is abandoned projects, resource leakage and poor public service delivery.

6. Raising the 50 per cent benchmark for statutory compliance

Setting the pass mark at 50 per cent implies that an institution can ignore half of its statutory obligations under the Fiscal Responsibility Act 2007 and still be recognised as meeting the standard.

Statutory compliance is not an academic examination where half-measures suffice—an agency either adheres to the law or is in breach. While we acknowledge the four ministries that crossed the 50 per cent mark, future editions of the index should progressively raise the benchmark to at least 70–75 per cent so that passing reflects genuine institutional discipline rather than minimal compliance.

READ ALSO: CeFTPI urges effective execution of Nigeria’s organised crime strategy

7. Strengthening the FRC’s funding, staffing and operational independence

An oversight regulator cannot effectively police over 1,000 federal MDAs and multi-billion-naira revenue-generating corporations while operating under severe funding constraints and staffing shortages.

CeFTPI urges the federal government and the National Assembly to place the Fiscal Responsibility Commission on First-Line Charge—alongside key judicial and anti-corruption institutions—and expand its technical and digital auditing capacity so it can execute its statutory mandate without financial or administrative bottlenecks.

8. Closing sub-national fiscal accountability gaps

While this assessment covers federal ministries, significant fiscal leakages also occur across the 36 states and 774 local government areas, many of which have either failed to domesticate the Fiscal Responsibility Act or maintain under-resourced state-level Fiscal Responsibility Commissions.

As increased Federation Account Allocation Committee (FAAC) revenues flow to sub-national governments, fiscal discipline at the state and local levels is critical. CeFTPI calls for a harmonised national accountability framework that links federal and sub-national fiscal oversight.

CeFTPI remains committed to collaborating with the Fiscal Responsibility Commission, the Bureau of Public Service Reforms (BPSR) and other oversight institutions to strengthen Nigeria’s public financial management architecture and ensure public resources translate into measurable development outcomes for citizens.

Umar Yakubu

Executive Director

Centre for Fiscal Transparency and Public Integrity (CeFTPI)

Abuja, Nigeria


Discover more from Premium Times Nigeria

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

admin

About Author

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may also like

National News

Court Dismisses Suit Challenging Emergence Of Abubakar Bawa As Taraba APC Chairman • Channels Television

  • November 19, 2026
  A Federal High Court sitting in Jalingo, Taraba State Capital, has dismissed the suit filed by Alhaji Abdulhadi Haruna
National News

‘Grand Theft Auto VI’ Launches Worldwide To Near-Perfect Reviews • Channels Television

  • November 19, 2026
  Gamers around the world got their first taste of “Grand Theft Auto VI” on Wednesday, as critics heaped praise